What Our Customers Say

4.9/5

Average rating

127+

Verified reviews

$580

Avg. annual savings

Saved over $640 a year on auto insurance

"Bayshield saved me over $640 a year on my auto insurance. The agent actually took the time to explain every coverage option instead of just pushing a policy. Highly recommend to anyone in the Tampa Bay area!"

Stress-free claims experience

"After my accident, they handled my claim so fast and made the whole process stress-free. I've never had an insurance company care this much. My agent checked in on me personally."

Incredible bundling savings

"We bundled our two cars and home and the savings were incredible — over $1,200 a year! Friendly, local, and responsive — exactly what you want from an agent."

Wish I'd switched sooner

"I switched from one of the big carriers and wish I'd done it sooner. Same coverage, way better price, and a real person who actually picks up the phone when I call."

Insurance made simple

"The quote took 12 minutes and saved me over $500 a year. Bayshield made insurance simple for the first time in my life. No jargon, no pressure, just honest advice."

Best decision for my business

"As a small business owner, I was overwhelmed by commercial insurance options. Bayshield built a custom policy that covers everything I need at a price I can afford. True professionals."

Re-shop saved me at renewal

"My old carrier jacked up my rates at renewal. Bayshield re-shopped my policy and found me better coverage for less. That's the kind of service that keeps you as a customer for life."

Home and auto bundle

"They found me a great home insurance policy and bundled it with my auto for a huge discount. The whole process took one phone call. Couldn't be happier."